Πειθούς Δημιουργός
HOW TO MAKE A RESOLUTION
WHAT IS IT ...
The draft resolution is a document which includes proposed measures in order to
solve the issue. You have to acknowledge facts and measures already taken and
propose new. The resolution has a very specific format which you must follow:
FORUM: (your Committee, e.g. Legal Committee)
QUESTION OF: (the topic, e.g. Human Cloning)
SUBMITTED BY: (your country, e.g. United States of America)
Pre-ambulatory clauses
These clauses are the introduction of the resolution. They contain the background and the argumentation to the issue you have chosen (such as historic background,important treaties, past UN resolutions, etc). Each clause begins with a preambulatory phrase and ends with a comma. These clauses do not take any action,since they are not debatable.
Operative clauses
Those are your suggested solutions and the measures that should be taken. Each
operative clause should be numbered, and should end with a semi-colon (;). The last operative clause should be followed by a period (.). Don’t forget that those
solutions must be similar to your country’s policy.
RESOLUTION ALWAYS CONTAIN :
1. A concise and evocative title (or number)
2. A list of Signatories
3. The name of the committee or the General Assembly
4. A set of PREAMBULATORY CLAUSES punctuated by semicolons (;)
5. An address to the Member states or voting parties
6. A set of OPERATIVE CLAUSES punctuated by commas (,)
7. A concluding clause punctuated by a period (.)
Once you write the resolution, save the document on a USB stick and print it or send it to your Advisor via e-mail. Don ’t forget to bring the USB to the Conference.
– Think of the “W” rule: Who, What, When, Why, hoW? When writing a clause, much like when writing an article, always ask yourself “does this follow the W rule”? If it does, and all these W questions have been answered, you can proceed onto the next golden rule.
Sample Resolution
1.Heading
In upper case
Font: Arial, Bold
Size: 12
2.Pre-amb clauses
Font: Arial, Italic
Size: 12
3.Operative clauses
Font: Arial,
Underline
Size: 12
Each operative clause must be numbered
Notes & Tips
-
All perambulatory clauses must end in commas (,)
-
All operative clauses must end in semi-colons (;)
-
All operative clauses must be underlined and numbered
-
Sub-operative clauses must be lettered; sub-sub operatives clauses must be in Roman Numerals
-
Leave 5 lines space between pre-ambulatory clauses and 1 line between every operative clause
All acronyms must be fully written out before appearing in the abbreviated form;
you only need to write them out once, and then refer to the abbreviated form
Delegates Manual| PS-MUN Conference
Pre-ambulatory clauses
Acknowledging Expecting Noting with appreciation
Affirming Expressing its appreciation Noting with approval
Alarmed by Expressing its satisfaction Noting with deep concern
Approving Fulfilling Noting with regret
Aware of Fully alarmed Noting with satisfaction
Believing Fully aware Observing
Bearing in mid Fully believing Pointing out
Confident Further deploring Reaffirming
Congratulating Further recalling Realizing
Convinced Guided by Recalling
Declaring Having adopted Recognising
Deeply concerned Having considered Referring
Deeply conscious Having devoted attention Reminding
Deeply disturbed Having examined Seeking
Deeply regretting Having received Taking into account
Deploring Having studied Taking into consideration
Desiring Keeping in mind Viewing with appreciation
Emphasizing Noting further Welcoming
Any of these clauses can be reused by adding “further” or “deeply” in front of it
All operatives clauses in bold can only be used by the Security Council
Operatives clauses
Accepts Deplores Requests
Affirms Designates Resolves
Approves Encourages Seeks
Asks Endorses Strongly affirms
Authorizes Expresses its satisfaction Strongly co
Calls for Expresses its hope Strongly urg
Calls upon Further recommends Suggests
Condemns Hopes Supports
Congratulates Invites Trusts
Confirms Proclaims Transmits
Decides Proposes Urges
Declares accordingly Recommends
Demands Regrets
When writing a set of operative clauses, here are some golden rules:
– Have a clear aim in mind. What is this particular clause trying to achieve?
– Be specific. Model United Nations, by its nature as a simulation, is prone to be taken less seriously. But do not forget that you are walking in the shoes of real-life diplomats, and learning skills that will last you a lifetime. Therefore, in international politics like many other things in life, precision is key. The more precision you add, the less loopholes are gonna be found by your opponents, so do yourself a huge favor and add numbers, names, countries, data, maps, whatever you deem necessary, and make good use of appendixes and annexes.
– Organize your resolution logically. Since it is all about convincing your audience (or the member states), to adopt your resolution, a seemingly logical construction will be your best ally. An argument is always more convincing when its development seems logical, because the conclusion reached will feel more natural. It can be chronological, consequential (one clause triggering another), hierarchies, etc…
– Think of the “W” rule: Who, What, When, Why, hoW? When writing a clause, much like when writing an article, always ask yourself “does this follow the W rule”? If it does, and all these W questions have been answered, you can proceed onto the next golden rule.
– There are never enough numbers. This rule cannot be stressed enough. When writing a clause, whether it is operative or preambulatory, it needs to be backed up with data. Is your aim to allocate funds to a cause? Write down how much money, its source, and the currency. Repeat as many times as necessary, without moderation.
– Subclauses are a thing, use them! Paragraph clauses are dull and messy, use sub
clauses as bullet points to make your argument clearer. Ask yourself if what you are about to write is thorough, original, concise yet satisfying enough to be its own clause, or would it be better off as a sub-clause in another, similar clause? Using subclauses will also make your resolution look more precise, more organized, clearer in its aim, and will allow the committee to discuss each point individually.
– Write as many preambulatory or operative clauses as you need. There is no rule that says you need more perambulatory or operative clauses. You need the right balance, depending on what you are discussing. Sometimes a few perambulatory clauses can lead to many operative clauses. Sometimes many perambulatory clauses can lead to a single course of action.(You can find an example of many preambles for one operative here. Scroll to “How to build a principled case: Example 1.”)
AMENDMENT
How Amendments Work
To amend is to make minor changes (in a text) in order to bring about a desired outcome. In MUN, amendments are specifically changes made to a draft resolution. These changes to clauses can either strengthen consensus or force countries to vote against it. Amendments are a strategic tool and an important part of the final stage of every MUN simulation.
The three types of amendments: CAR
Changing the text of a clause / sub clause
Adding a new clause / sub clause
Removing a clause / sub clause
Your CAR will drive change in the resolution!
Amendments are included in this resolution writing article because they follow the same rules for writing as clauses for a draft resolution. The only difference is that amendments are added individually after a draft has been officially recognized and need to be voted into the draft to become part of it.
Amendments require a certain number of delegates to sign them before they can be submitted to the chair for review. Amendments can be submitted at any point in time after a draft resolution is recognized until it is voted upon. If amendments are voted on before or after closure of debate depends on each conferences specific rules of procedure.
MUN amendments divide into friendly amendments and unfriendly amendments.
Friendly amendments are a change to the draft resolution that all sponsors agree with. If the amendment is also approved by the chair no vote is required and it automatically becomes part of the draft resolution.
Unfriendly amendments are when one, or more, of the sponsors do not agree with the change. Unfriendly amendments can both strengthen or weaken a resolution, resulting in more or less votes and can even force sponsors to vote against the document they drafted. Unfriendly amendments are typically voted on in order of severity (the order of voting is usually established by the Chair).
Once the debate is closed the committee moves into formal voting procedure. At this point unfriendly amendments, if any, are voted upon followed by the draft resolutions.
Once the debate is closed the committee moves into formal voting procedure. At this point unfriendly amendments, if any, are voted upon followed by the draft resolutions.
Remember:
– Preambulatory clauses – Why we’re doing it
– Operative clauses – What we’re going to do
Clauses should be written:
– – Without emotion
– – Straight forward instructions (to be carried out by bureaucrats)
– – Preferably with little wiggle room (unless that is the goal)
Especially for MUN rooms with other advanced delegates, make sure your operative clauses are backed by preambs, the clauses are presented in order of importance and you have at least one clause which justifies why you are not merging with another block.